The Irish Whiteboard Experience?

When I was full time in a classroom I was fortunate to have access to an interactive whiteboard. Initially we had quite a steep learning curve climb to get the board working efficiently. (We did the board installation using labour from within the school community working from the support documents that came with the board, CRAZY!!!).

Soon things were running quite nicely such that I even decided to blog about my experiences. After a couple of years working with it when I moved from that room to another room without a board, my teaching life became quite traumatic. I have also since presented at a number of conferences on the use of IWB’s including at the last three national IWBnet conferences. Any time IWB’s are talked about, one of the major points of discussion that arises is the hoary old question of the best board brand or type. To my mind this is a self defeating and fairly pointless excercise, any board used well is a great investment in time and money but the best board in the world used inefficiently is an incredible waste of resources.

It was interesting then to read a recent post from Simon Lewis, an Irish Education consultant who also has a blog at Anseo.net. During an IWB course that he was conducting recently he managed to get together five different types of IWB’s for the participants to evaluate. As part of the exercise Simon surveyed the participants in as he said

“…….to check out all the options without interfering salespeople then surveyed them on their experiences.”

Simon then summarized the results in a pdf document. To me the interesting aspect of all of this is not so much the results, but Simon’s discussions and reflections on the reasons given by the teachers. One would also wonder what would be the reactions of non-novice users?

\Bored or the Board\

For those interested, I have also posted the details contained in this post on the IWBnet Conference Ning in the interest of stimulating discussion there as well.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Tools, Uncategorized and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to The Irish Whiteboard Experience?

  1. Barbara says:

    Spot on! Thanks for another timely post! I have resisted IWB’s because of cost and my perception about bang for the buck but it may be time to reconsider. The PDF summary was quite interesting.hope Mimio and others read it too!

  2. John says:

    Hi John,
    Nice to see the comparison. Might be worth thinking about stage. I ‘ve been using a smartboard for the last couple of years fairly regularly. Leaning towards a wireless keyboard and gyromouse for Primary 7 next session. A very cheap solution compared to a whiteboard.

  3. Simon Lewis says:

    Hi! Thanks for the report about my survey – didn’t realise that I’d reached so many people. Just for the record, although I’m flattered to be referred to as a educational consultant, I’m merely a teacher who gives ICT courses in my spare time! Glad you found it interesting anyway 🙂

  4. johnp says:

    Hi Simon,
    Ah the wonders of this connected environment we now live in. Your survey has provoked quite a bit of interest in my network, I have also posted it to http://iwbnet.ning.com/forum/topic/show?id=2007476%3ATopic%3A1241

    More power to you if you are both working in a school and doing PD in your spare time. As one who has done just this until recently I hope your peers appreciate your work as much as others do.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s